DVDAttitude

Les Inrockuptiblesse distinguent dans leur top 20



1 Last days
2 Les Amants reguliers
3 A History of violence
4 Three Times
5 Peindre ou faire l'amour
6 La Vie Aquatique
7 Match Point
8 Peau de cochon
9 The World
10 The Taste of tea
11 Edward Munch
12 Mysterious Skin
13 A Travers la foret
14 La Guerre des mondes
15 Be with me
16 1/3 des yeux
17 Mary
18 La blessure
19 Le Cauchemar de Darwin
20 Le Petit Lieutenant

Les deux journalistes de Associated Pressproposent leur top 10

David Germain:
1. Dear Frankie
2. King Kong
3. A History of Violence
4. Transamerica
5. Capote
6. Syriana
7. Grizzly Man
8. Broken Flowers
9. The Producers
10. The 40-Year-Old Virgin

Christy Lemire:
1. The Squid and the Whale
2. Capote
3. Syriana
4. Good Night, and Good Luck
5. Murderball
6. Crash
7. The Upside of Anger
8. Broken Flowers
9. Tell Them Who You Are
10. Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit

Le Chicago Suntimes dévoile son top 10 à travers son critique Roger Ebert

1 Crash
2 Syriana
3 Munich
4 Junebug
5 Brokeback Mountain
6 Me and You and Everyone We Know
7 Nine Lives
8 King kong
9 Yes
10 Millions

La critique du magazine People, Leah Rozen, propose son top 10.

1 ) A History of Violence
2 ) Crash
3 ) Brokeback Mountain
4 ) King Kong
5 ) Munich
6 ) The Squid and the Whale
7 ) Walk the Line
8 ) Capote
9 ) Good Night, And Good Luck.
10) Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit

Les trois critiques du Los Angeles Times affichent leur sélection 2005.

KENNETH TURAN
1. "The Best of Youth" & "Duma"
2. "Paradise Now" & "Syriana"
3. "The Squid and the Whale" & "Brokeback Mountain"
4. "Howl's Moving Castle" & "Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit"
5. "A History of Violence" & "Munich"
6. "Los Angeles Plays Itself"
7. "Capote" & "Good Night, and Good Luck"
8. "Batman Begins" & "King Kong"
9. "Head-On"
10. "The Constant Gardener"

CARINA CHOCANO
"2046" (Wong Kar Wai)
"Brokeback Mountain" (Ang Lee)
"Capote" (Bennett Miller)
"The Corporation" (Mark Achbar, Jennifer Abbott, Joel Bakan)
"The Edukators" (Hans Weingartner)
"Grizzly Man" (Werner Herzog)
"Head-On" (Fatih Akin)
"Junebug" (Phil Morrison)
"King Kong" (Peter Jackson)
"Last Days" (Gus Van Sant)
"The Squid and the Whale" (Noah Baumbach)
"Syriana" (Stephen Gaghan)
"Turtles Can Fly" (Bahman Ghobadi)

KEVIN THOMAS
1. "Mysterious Skin"
2. "Brokeback Mountain"
3. "Crash"
4. "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada"
5. "Garçon Stupide"
6. "Hustle & Flow"
7. "Ballets Russes"
8. "Tropical Malady"
9. "Keane"
10. "The Holy Girl"

Le magazine britannique Total Film présente son top 20 :

1. Sideways
2. Batman Begins
3. Murderball
4. Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang
5. The Descent
6. Sin City
7. A History Of Violence
8. Million Dollar Baby
9. Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge Of The Sith
10. Kung Fu Hustle
11. Crash
12. Saraband
13. Wedding Crashers
14. Mysterious Skin
15. Wolf Creek
16. Lord Of War
17. The Constant Gardener
18. Somersault
19. Serenity
20. Innocence

L'hebdomadaireTéléramadévoile ses tops 10

Le choix de la rédaction

1 Le cauchemar de Darwin
2 Match Point
3 De battre mon coeur s'est arrêté
4 Caché
5 Broken Flowers
6 L'enfant
7 La vie aquatique
8 Mysterious Skin
9 Le temps qui reste
10 Peindre ou faire l'amour

Le choix des lecteurs

1 Million Dollar Baby
2 Match Point
3 Broken Flowers
4 De battre mon coeur s'est arrêté
5 L'enfant
6 Les poupées russes
7 La marche de l'empereur
8 A history of violence
9 Le cauchemar de Darwin
10 Le promeneur du Champ-de-Mars

Le choix des 2 critiques du Time
Richard Corliss
01. The White Diamond
02. Saraband
03. 2046
04. The Squid and the Whale
05. Caché
06. The New World
07. The Constant Gardener
08. Kung Fu Hustle
09. Memoirs of a Geisha
10. Chicken Little; Wallace and Gromit in the Curse of the Were-Rabbit; and Millions

Richard Schickel
02. Downfall
03. Memory of a Killer
04. The Weather Man
05. Munich
06. Caché
07. The Beat That My Heart Skipped
08. Crash
09. Cinderella Man
10. Ballet Russes

Le top 5 de Libé

Les Amants réguliers de Philippe Garrel
A History of Violence de David Cronenberg
The World de Jia Zhangke
La Vie aquatique de Wes Anderson
Keane de Lodge Kerrigan

Les tops 10 des critiques de la revue américaine Entertainment Weekly :

Owen Gleiberman
01. Munich
02. King Kong
03. Brokeback Mountain
04. The Century of the Self
05. Match Point
06. Junebug
07. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
08. Hustle & Flow
09. In Her Shoes
10. Tony Takitani

Lisa Schwarzbaum
01. A History of Violence
02. Brokeback Mountain
03. The Best of Youth
04. King Kong
05. Munich
06. The World
07. Me and You and Everyone We Know
08. Crash
09. 2046
10. Look at Me

Chronic'Artdévoile son top 10 :

01. A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE - DAVID CRONENBERG
02. MILLION DOLLAR BABY - CLINT EASTWOOD
03. LA GUERRE DES MONDES - STEVEN SPIELBERG
04. THE TASTE OF TEA - KATSUHITO ISHII
05. LAST DAYS - GUS VAN SANT
06. LA VIE AQUATIQUE - WES ANDERSON
07. LES AMANTS REGULIERS - PHILIPPE GAREL
08. SEVEN SWORDS - TSUI HARK
09. MARY - ABEL FERRARA
10. BE WITH ME - ERIC KHOO

Le top 10 de MCinema

1- Million Dollar Baby
2- Mysterious Skin
3- Wallace et Gromit
4- Charlie et la chocolaterie
5- Match Point
6- Le cauchemar de Darwin
7- Star Wars Episode III
8- Le petit lieutenant
9- Aviator
10- Les Noces funèbres